Debates & Controversies

Thoughtful coverage of ongoing discussions in the field — RCTs versus observational methods, external validity, ethics, bias, and the limits of causal claims.

Posterior or Sampling Distribution? The Bayesian-Frequentist Debate in Causal Inference

Read more →

Do Causal Estimates Travel? External Validity and the Credibility Revolution in Development

Read more →

Dynamic Difference-in-Differences: Are Event Study Coefficients Reliable Estimates of Causal Dynamics?

Read more →

Are Regression Discontinuity Designs Actually Identifying What We Think? Manipulation, Heaping, and the Limits of Continuity

Read more →

Harvesting Causal Estimates: Can We Meta-Analyse DiD and Event-Study Results?

Read more →

Machine Learning or Theory for Covariate Selection? A Methodological Debate

Read more →

Mediation Analysis: Can We Ever Identify Indirect Effects?

Read more →

Machine Learning or Economic Theory? The Debate Over Covariate Selection in Applied Economics

Read more →

Reduced Form vs Structural Models: Do We Need Theory for External Validity?

Read more →

Treatment Effect Heterogeneity: Feature or Bug in Policy Evaluation?

Read more →

Should Long-Run Effects of Short-Run Interventions Be Trusted?

Read more →

Clustering Standard Errors: When, Why, and At What Level?

Read more →

Pooling vs. Stratification: Should Policy Evaluations Report Subgroup Effects?

Read more →

The Replication Crisis in Economics: Beyond Pre-registration

Read more →

Is Every "Natural Experiment" Really Natural? Scrutinising the Exclusion Restriction

Read more →

Selection on Parallel Trends: The Hidden Assumption Behind Conditional DiD

Read more →

Machine Learning versus Structural Models: Two Visions of Policy Counterfactuals

Read more →

Publication Bias and the File Drawer Problem: Are Published Effect Sizes Too Big?

Read more →

Synthetic Control vs. Difference-in-Differences: When to Use Which?

Read more →

Should Covariates Always Be Included in Randomised Experiments?

Read more →

The Parallel Trends Assumption: Testable, Credible, or Dogma?

Read more →

RCTs vs. Observational Studies: Is Randomisation the Gold Standard?

Read more →

Pre-registration and Researcher Degrees of Freedom: Does Economics Have a Replication Problem?

Read more →

External Validity: Are Local Average Treatment Effects Policy-Relevant?

Read more →